EnglishIndiaEducation News
User

NEET-UG Paper Leak Case: Kulkarni's Counsel Argues He Is Not a Public Servant

In the NEET-UG paper leak case, Kulkarni's counsel argued that he is not a public servant, according to the reported legal proceedings.

By ShikshapediaUpdated: 10 September 2026

NEET-UG 2026 Paper Leak Case: Kulkarni Challenges CBI's 'Public Servant' Claim as Court Hears Charges Against 13 Accused

NEET-UG 2026 Paper Leak Case: A fresh legal argument has emerged in the high-profile NEET-UG paper leak proceedings, with counsel for accused Prahlad Vithalrao Kulkarni arguing before a Delhi court that his client cannot be treated as a "public servant" merely because he was associated with work performed for the National Testing Agency.

The submission was made during arguments on the framing of charges before the Rouse Avenue Court, where the Special Fast Track Court is considering the case against 13 accused persons.

Kulkarni's lawyers have disputed several allegations made by the Central Bureau of Investigation, including the nature of his role in the examination process, the claim that he was entrusted with confidential examination material and the allegation that students received leaked questions through him.

The court is currently hearing arguments on charges. The defence submissions are claims made on behalf of the accused and do not amount to judicial findings. Likewise, allegations made by the CBI remain subject to adjudication.

What Did Kulkarni's Counsel Argue?

Advocate Hemant Shah, appearing for Kulkarni, argued that although the National Testing Agency is a public authority conducting public examinations, that fact by itself does not automatically make every person associated with its examination work a public servant.

The defence submitted that Kulkarni's position had not been formally notified as that of a public servant under the relevant legal framework.

IssueDefence Position
Kulkarni's statusCounsel argues he was not a notified public servant
NTA statusDefence accepts NTA is a public authority
Question-paper roleDefence disputes the CBI's characterisation of entrustment
Money allegationDefence says the alleged money transaction is disputed
Student visitsDefence questions evidence of students visiting Kulkarni's residence
Confidentiality documentCounsel describes it as an undertaking or contractual document

Why Does 'Public Servant' Status Matter?

The legal classification can matter because particular offences and statutory provisions may depend on the status, duty or capacity in which an accused person was functioning.

The defence is therefore not making a purely descriptive argument. It is challenging part of the legal foundation on which certain allegations may be framed.

Whether the court accepts that interpretation will depend on the applicable statutory provisions, the nature of Kulkarni's engagement and the evidence placed on record.

What Has the CBI Alleged About Kulkarni?

The CBI has alleged that Kulkarni, a chemistry subject expert associated with the NEET-UG examination process, had access to confidential examination questions.

Earlier in the investigation, the agency described him as a significant accused in the alleged leak and claimed that confidential material was improperly taken out of the secured examination-preparation process.

Investigators have also alleged that special coaching sessions were held before the NEET-UG examination and that material linked with the examination reached candidates through an alleged network.

These remain prosecution allegations and should not be presented as established guilt.

What Did the Defence Say About the Alleged Special Classes?

Kulkarni's counsel questioned the evidence supporting allegations that students came to his residence before the examination.

The lawyer argued that there was no residential-access or MyGate record placed on record showing the alleged visits in the manner claimed.

The defence also disputed that leaked papers were handed directly to students and questioned the prosecution's claims relating to monetary transactions.

What is the Court Deciding Right Now?

The court is currently hearing arguments on the framing of charges.

This stage comes before a full criminal trial on the merits.

At this point, the court examines whether the material placed before it provides sufficient legal basis to frame particular charges against individual accused persons.

Framing of Charges vs Conviction: What is the Difference?

Framing of ChargesConviction
Occurs before trial evidence is fully testedOccurs after the judicial process establishes guilt
Identifies offences the accused may faceDetermines criminal responsibility
Does not establish guiltRequires the applicable legal standard to be met

This distinction is especially important in high-profile examination cases where allegations receive extensive public attention long before the trial concludes.

How Did the NEET-UG 2026 Leak Investigation Begin?

The CBI registered the case in May following a complaint from the Department of Higher Education regarding alleged irregularities surrounding the NEET-UG examination.

Investigators subsequently arrested multiple individuals and examined alleged links involving subject experts, intermediaries, coaching-related contacts and candidates.

The alleged mechanism described during the investigation differed from the conventional image of a printed examination booklet being stolen from a printing press.

Investigators have instead examined whether confidential questions were extracted during stages connected with question preparation, translation and proofreading.

Why is the NEET Paper Leak Case So Important?

NEET-UG determines admission opportunities for a very large number of medical aspirants competing for MBBS and other medical seats.

Any credible allegation involving confidential examination material therefore raises several concerns:

  • Fairness to candidates who prepared legitimately
  • Security of national entrance examinations
  • Confidentiality protocols
  • Accountability of experts handling question papers
  • Technology used to track examination material
  • Protection against organised cheating networks
  • Public confidence in competitive examinations

What is the Public Examinations Law?

India introduced the Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024 as part of efforts to address organised cheating and examination-related malpractice.

The law targets specified unfair means relating to public examinations and creates criminal consequences for conduct falling within its provisions.

In the current proceedings, defence lawyers have also raised questions concerning the legality and manner of the investigation under the statutory framework.

What Could Happen Next?

The court will continue hearing submissions from counsel representing the remaining accused. After considering the prosecution and defence arguments, it can determine what charges, if any, should formally proceed against each accused.

The case would then move through subsequent stages in accordance with criminal procedure.

NEET Paper Leak Case FAQs

Who is P V Kulkarni?
He is a former chemistry lecturer who was associated with NEET examination-related work for the NTA and is an accused in the CBI's 2026 paper-leak case.

What is his lawyer arguing now?
The defence argues that Kulkarni should not be legally treated as a public servant because his position was not notified as such.

Has the court accepted this argument?
The court is currently hearing arguments on framing of charges. The defence argument should not be confused with a final judicial ruling.

How many accused are involved in the current charge proceedings?
The Special Fast Track Court is hearing charge arguments concerning 13 accused persons.

Has Kulkarni been convicted?
No conviction is established merely because a person is accused or because charges are being considered.

NEET-UG Leak Case: Final Takeaway

The latest hearing adds a significant legal question to the NEET-UG paper leak case: what was the precise legal status of experts engaged by the NTA to handle confidential examination work?

The answer could influence how parts of the prosecution case are framed, but the wider proceedings involve numerous allegations and accused persons.

For candidates following the case, the crucial distinction is between allegations, defence arguments, framed charges and proven guilt. The court—not the headline—will ultimately determine the legal responsibility of each accused.