Could NEET Be Held Twice a Year? Bengaluru Experts Suggest Class 12 Weightage, Mental Aptitude Test and Major Exam Reforms
India Examination Reforms: A high-level discussion in Bengaluru has produced a wide range of proposals that could reshape how entrance examinations such as NEET and JEE are conducted in India.
Education experts, regulators, students, mental-health specialists and institutional representatives met at an event organised by the Centre for Educational and Social Studies to develop suggestions for the national high-powered task force on examination reforms led by Nandan Nilekani.
Ideas discussed included holding NEET multiple times, giving weightage to Class 12 marks, testing mental aptitude and general ability, creating question banks and changing how entrance-test papers are generated.
Major Exam Reform Ideas Discussed
| Proposal | Possible Objective |
|---|---|
| Add biology to a JEE-style model | Create alternative medical entrance architecture |
| Give Class 12 marks weightage | Reduce dependence on one exam |
| Mental aptitude/general ability test | Measure qualities beyond memorisation |
| Multiple exam dates | Reduce single-day pressure |
| Question bank | Strengthen paper security and standardisation |
| Paper generated close to exam time | Reduce leak risk |
| Parent counselling videos | Address stress and expectations |
S Somanath Raises Question of NEET Paper Ownership
S Somanath, a member of the high-powered task force, contrasted the way JEE and NEET are organised.
He noted that IIT professors are directly associated with JEE paper setting and that individual IITs take institutional ownership of conducting the examination.
He argued that NEET does not have the same kind of institutional ownership.
Could Question Papers Be Created Minutes Before the Exam?
One idea discussed was creating a large secure question bank and generating the final examination paper shortly before the test.
A properly designed system could potentially reduce opportunities for advance paper leaks.
However, such a system would require:
- Extremely strong cybersecurity
- Statistical equivalence of questions
- Secure exam-centre delivery
- Audit trails
- Reliable encryption
Should Class 12 Marks Count in NEET?
MK Ramesh of the National Medical Commission's Medical Assessment and Rating Board suggested that 50% weightage could be given to Class 12 results.
Supporters may argue this would reduce dependence on one high-pressure test.
Critics would immediately raise another problem: school boards have different marking patterns and difficulty levels.
The Board Normalisation Problem
A CBSE score, Kerala board score and another state board score cannot automatically be compared as though every examination had identical difficulty and marking.
Any national system using Class 12 scores would therefore need a statistically defensible normalisation mechanism.
State Rank Plus NEET Rank?
IISc computer-science professor Y Narahari suggested a possible combination of:
- A state-level rank based on Class 12 performance
- An all-India rank based on NEET
States could potentially build final merit using both components.
But What About Older NEET Candidates?
Somanath highlighted a practical challenge: NEET does not have a simple upper age limit equivalent to school-leaver-only examinations.
If Class 12 marks receive major weightage, what happens when a candidate completed school decades ago?
This illustrates how a reform that sounds simple can create fairness problems when applied nationally.
A JEE-Type Exam With Biology?
PES University's Jawahar Doreswamy suggested adapting JEE-style testing for medicine by adding biology.
His proposal included multiple examinations on alternate weekends and allowing candidates more than one attempt.
A model could include a structured difficulty mix:
- 50% easier questions
- 30% moderate questions
- 20% difficult questions
Could NEET Be Held Twice a Year?
A BMCRI student proposed holding NEET twice annually and onboarding two student batches each year.
Advantages could include:
- A second chance after illness or poor performance
- Reduced pressure on one examination date
- Potentially smoother seat utilisation
But twice-yearly admission could create major challenges for:
- Medical college calendars
- Clinical rotations
- Faculty workload
- Internship schedules
Mental Health Is Part of Exam Reform
NIMHANS expert Suresh Bada Math emphasised that parents should understand the pressure associated with professional education.
Exam reform is therefore not only about question papers.
It can include:
- Student stress
- Coaching pressure
- Parent expectations
- Career counselling
- Failure resilience
Are These Changes Already Approved?
No.
These are stakeholder suggestions.
The proposals are intended to be submitted to the high-powered task force on examination reforms.
They should not be reported as final government decisions.
Exam Reform FAQs
Is NEET becoming twice a year?
Not yet. Twice-yearly NEET was one of the ideas discussed.
Will Class 12 marks get 50% weightage?
This was proposed by a stakeholder, not approved as policy.
Who leads the national exam-reform task force?
The high-powered task force is led by Nandan Nilekani.
Why was the Bengaluru meeting held?
To collect stakeholder ideas for improving examination systems.
Final Takeaway
The Bengaluru discussion shows that exam reform is moving beyond questions such as “paper or computer?”
Experts are debating the much bigger issue: whether one three-hour entrance test should continue carrying so much weight in determining a student's professional future.
Whether any of these proposals become policy will depend on evidence, fairness, feasibility and the recommendations ultimately accepted by the government.










